I'd already tried the regular Infallible gloss and really liked it, as it has great staying power. The plumping gloss is basically the same formula with the added benefit of a plumper. It doesn't flake off or have that "plastic-y" look like lots of other long-lasting products. It stays fresh and gorgeous for hours.
I really like the Plumped Red shade. Despite the brightness of the tube, the application is sheer and a lot more toned-down. This is a great gloss for anyone who really wants to try red, but is too scared to go for the real deal.
The best part? The gloss is under $10!