Bath and Body Works Give Good Cheer lotion set ($10). Bath and Body Works actually has a ton of inexpensive gift ideas. I could probably get all of my holiday shopping done there. This set is great though. I mean, everyone I know loves lotion. The big bow and packaging make it adorable.
E.L.F. Nail Polish Set ($6). This is a perfect set. And if you're reeeaaally broke, you could even break up the set--get some candy or something little and throw it and a polish in a cute decorative plastic baggie (they have packs of them at any craft store for a couple dollars), and tie the top with a big bow.
Voluspa French Cade & Lavender Candle in Decorative Tin ($9). There's something that feels so decadent about a pretty, luxurious candle. This looks like it could cost a lot more than $9 and the tin is reusable. Plus it's smells amazing!
Borghese Spatacular Treats Set ($9.99). This has a retail value of $45, so the quality is there. It's a five-piece beauty set and it comes with a gorgey pink bag! 90% of all women would love this. I promise.
Too Faced Fabulous Face Trio ($9.99). This has all the girly essentials: lip gloss, glitter and tissues. What's not to love?